Kelly Carroll

Portrait photo of Kelly Carroll

St. Charles

950 Caledonia Drive
O’Fallon, MO 63368

Office Phone: 636-720-1100



                            START YOUR SEARCH NOW WITH ME…

Our company, Select Properties, when formed in 2002, was created to keep our local market. . . well. . . local. St. Louis is our hometown. We grew up here. We live here. We work here. Who knows, you and I may even be neighbors.

The thing is, I know St. Louis and all the surrounding counties. I know its neighborhoods – we go to the Hill for Italian, hit the Loop for people watching and know Dogtown is the place to be on St. Patty’s day.   We were here when the Arena went down and can remember when Wildwood was actually country.

We know its quirks. Our favorite summer treat is handed to us upside down too. We can correctly (ahem or should I say incorrectly) say Gravois, Chouteau and Spoede.

But most of all, I know its market . . . because I live in the market, specifically St. Charles County.  Our decisions are made based on the same trends that your family experiences right down the street.


Select Properties, formed in 2002, now has 10 offices in the St. Louis Metropolitan area, which includes 2 offices in St. Charles County, 1 office in Lincoln and 1 office in Jefferson County… representing over 550 agents. My Office ranks #1 in the entire company.  We're ranked #26 in the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices national network, ranked #2 in the St. Louis Business Journal Book of Lists of Top Real Estate firms, #2 in real estate transactions recorded by the St. Louis Association of Realtors and in the top 20% of real estate firms nationwide. We rank as the #1 locally-owned real estate firm in St. Louis.   Maryann Vitale, Deb Colburn and Angie Ignatowski share ownership of the company, ranking #18 in Women Owned Companies by the St. Louis Business Journal.

Our Mission, Our Vision, Our Values

To provide the highest quality real estate brokerage service to my clients and customers and to be recognized in the community for high standards and ethics.

My guiding principle is simply doing the right thing every day to earn the trust and respect of each other, my clients and customers.

At Select Properties we put honesty, morality, and ethics first. We value providing service to our customers, clients, and each other in the real estate community that out-performs expectations. We also provide a positive environment that is based on faith and principle which rewards commitment to excellence and contributes to the personal growth of the individual and encourages life balance.

Licensed In


Ask Kelly Carroll


Kelly Carroll is the consummate professional! From knowledge of the market, initiative in tracking down information, to responsiveness and a wonderful personality to wrap it up, we could not have been happier with her as our agent. She is so knowledgeable and handled the sale of our home in an efficient and professional manner.

She has also been a blessing on the purchase of our new home (new construction). She knows what questions to ask and has keen eye and level of expertise second to none. Without reservation, I would recommend Kelly Carroll to anyone wishing to have a professional, knowledgeable real estate agent.

- Brad and Chris Garland, Dardenne Prairie , MO

Kelly made an immediate impact on our negotiations with the seller. She initiated numerous contacts with the seller as our advocate and we credit her with us receiving what we believe to be a very good deal. She was invaluable in the several inspections of the home we conducted because she has an acute eye for detail and noticed things we would never have seen. During the closing process she was on vacation, but responded to questions almost immediately and she made herself available during the closing meeting via phone. She also has a great design eye and helped us make decisions on colors and other variable items. Would definitely recommend. Thanks Kelly!

- Steve Dykas O'Fallen Mo

Experience working with corporate relocation situations was a key part of my selection process. Peggy and Kelly were an excellent team to work with during our relocation process. I am using another Berkshire Agent to find our new home out of state.

- Daryl Allen, Carmel, Indiana

My wife and I have used Kelly for two sales and two purchases in the past few years. I wouldn't even consider using anyone else but Kelly.

Kelly made me feel very comfortable selling and buying..... Kelly made several calls updating us on progress throughout the selling and buying process. I felt like I was in good hands with Kelly though out what can be a very stressful time.... While searching for a condo for my boys, she toured me through several homes that she had set up showings for and even drove me around in her personal vehicle. After weeks of searching and showings I found the perfect place to call home for my Kids...… Thanks Kelly, TOP NOTCH service.

Jeff Preis

- Jeff Preis, Lake St. Louis Missouri

Very professional, knew the area, listen to my needs and found the home.

None better

I could not have asked for anything more.....

- Jeff Preis , Lake St. Louis Missouri

Kelly was very knowable in what needed to be done in both selling our home plus the buying of our villa She made the signing of all documents easy to understand & explained each as we signed them. We trusted & had confident in her honesty & professional advice pertaining to all matters with the sale & buying. I would definitely recommend her & her partner Peggy Trittler to family & friends.

- Joe Gentile O'Fallon ,MO

We knew from a relative that Kelly was eager to sell our home at the best possible price.

Kelly approached us with a positive attitude towards the sale of our home. She represented our home through pictures,advertising & open house to the best of her ability, which made for a quick sale, at the right price. She was very efficient after the sale as well, with the signing of documents & closing.

We can understand why Kelly Carroll is a successful agent, her attitude, knowledge & friendliness are the best.

- Joe Gentile Ofallon MO

I knew Kelly Carroll personally from our association working in the community we both live in.

We signed the contract with Kelly on Monday, February 4th with the intent of actively listing it on March 1st. Kelly put the coming soon sign up after signing. On Friday, February 8th, Kelly contacted us by email to set up a date to show to show our home when we got back from a trip on Monday February 11th because she had three people who wanted to look at our home. She inquired if we could have the home ready by Thursday, February 21st and by that day, she had a fourth person interested. The buyers wrote an offer for the asking price that day. I cannot speak highly enough about her follow up and guidance from that point to closing. Her professionalism and expertise were exemplary. Besides being an excellent agent, she is a great person who goes above and beyond.

My wife and I cannot stress enough how wonderful Kelly was to work with. Any agent could learn to be a better agent just by observing Kelly in action.

- Ken & Marcia Albridge

Kelly's knowledge of new construction pricing was invaluable to us. The info Kelly provided helped us to make a serius offer where we could negotiate a very good price from the builder.

- Bob, Saint Charles

I would highly recommend Kelly Carrol. She does an amazing job and I will definitely use her again when selling or buying a home.

- Torie Bryant, Lake Saint Louis

Kelly was exceptional throughout the entire process! Being a first time home buyer, she spent time to help me understand each part of the home buying process, which made me more confident and comfortable in my decisions with different properties.

- Andrea B., St. Louis

Kelly was always concerned with our best interests and not in the interest of getting a deal done. We have full confidence in her and will recommend her to others looking for an agent.

- Jim Schlueter

Kelly was extremely helpful and knowledgeable with the selling of my home. She always was easily assessable and I felt that she always had by best interest in mind.

- jodi Sklencar

Both Kelly and Peggy were phenomenal to work with. They were realistic with me on price for both properties that I was selling. They were very attentive to the fact that I was a mom of 3 young kids that was amidst relocating across country. I could not recommend the team enough. They are fabulous in so many ways and their hard work and their ability to deliver should be recognized! Thanks for everything!

The Neitzel Family

- Leandra Neitzel