Melissa Reynolds

Portrait photo of Melissa Reynolds

St. Charles

950 Caledonia Drive
O’Fallon, MO 63368

Office: 636-720-1100



                            START YOUR SEARCH NOW WITH ME…

Our company, Select Properties, when formed in 2002, was created to keep our local market. . . well. . . local. St. Louis is our hometown. We grew up here. We live here. We work here. Who knows, you and I may even be neighbors.

The thing is, I know St. Louis and all the surrounding counties. I know its neighborhoods – we go to the Hill for Italian, hit the Loop for people watching and know Dogtown is the place to be on St. Patty’s day.   We were here when the Arena went down and can remember when Wildwood was actually country.

We know its quirks. Our favorite summer treat is handed to us upside down too. We can correctly (ahem or should I say incorrectly) say Gravois, Chouteau and Spoede.

But most of all, I know its market . . . because I live in the market, specifically St. Charles County.  Our decisions are made based on the same trends that your family experiences right down the street.


Select Properties, formed in 2002, now has 10 offices in the St. Louis Metropolitan area, which includes 2 offices in St. Charles County, 1 office in Lincoln and 1 office in Jefferson County… representing over 550 agents. My Office ranks #1 in the entire company.  We're ranked #26 in the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices national network, ranked #2 in the St. Louis Business Journal Book of Lists of Top Real Estate firms, #2 in real estate transactions recorded by the St. Louis Association of Realtors and in the top 20% of real estate firms nationwide. We rank as the #1 locally-owned real estate firm in St. Louis.   Maryann Vitale, Deb Colburn and Angie Ignatowski share ownership of the company, ranking #18 in Women Owned Companies by the St. Louis Business Journal.

Our Mission, Our Vision, Our Values

To provide the highest quality real estate brokerage service to my clients and customers and to be recognized in the community for high standards and ethics.

My guiding principle is simply doing the right thing every day to earn the trust and respect of each other, my clients and customers.

At Select Properties we put honesty, morality, and ethics first. We value providing service to our customers, clients, and each other in the real estate community that out-performs expectations. We also provide a positive environment that is based on faith and principle which rewards commitment to excellence and contributes to the personal growth of the individual and encourages life balance.

Service Areas

63304, 63303, 63376, 63385

Licensed In


Ask Gittemeier & Reynolds Realty Partners


Very helpful finding me the right place and patiently answered my numerous questions. Amazing service from start to finish. I would highly recommend.

- Lawrence B

Melissa was fantastic to work with. My search area for a home was wide but she was willing to run anywhere an everywhere with me until I found my home!

- Adam N

Well I’m not sure what to say because I didn’t even talk to Melissa on the phone I dealt with Bonnie Gittimeire. Melissa sent me forms in a timely manner and answered any questions I had. Bonnie took care of staging an open house she was available to me 24 seven if I had any questions which was nice because I was out of state.

- Clayton,N D

We had a buyer before the house was on the market. Melissa helped us with all the paperwork and items needed to complete the sale. She did an excellent job and was very helpful with questions that came up. Melissa also answered the buyers questions. She made this process so simple.

- Dave C

I was very pleased with the efforts of the Berkshire Hathaway team working with me. Bonnie has a great team and used them well, to get the property listed, shown and sold. Smooth and seamless.

- MO H

Melissa has worked with my daughter and son in law on buying and selling property and did a great job. Her and her team are outstanding and very aware of our want and needs. Could not have asked for anyone better. Again, always on top of the process. Excellent communication. Entire team, outstanding. Bonnie was fantastic. Could not have asked for more. Everything was very well done.

- St M

Just from our years working together, I knew she would be a great fit for us. Melissa was professional, understanding, straightforward, and great to work with throughout the homebuying process.

- Drew W

Melissa went above and beyond to help me sell my home. She even went so far as to meet contractors at my house for fixes, when I was not able to. She really is the best!

- St. C

We love Bonnie Cavanaugh Gittemier!!!!!!!!!!!!!! We love Bonnie Cavanaugh Gittemier & Melissa Reynolds!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

- ST. K

We love Bonnie Cavanaugh Gittemier & Melissa Reynolds!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She sold in just a few DAYS!!! We love Bonnie Cavanaugh Gittemier!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

- Kevin A

Dealt mostly with her partner, Bonnie, but both were great to work with. My home was sold on the first day of the open house. Needless to say, I was pleased.

- Carolyn C

I talked with other agents in different companies and I did not trust them after a few minutes of talking to them. We contacted Melissa Renolds and felt very comfortable within minutes. I will recommend Melissa to anyone. She is very trustworthy. She also paid attention to what we wanted without hesitation. She made very it a fun experience because she also has a great sence of humor.

- Chris M

Melissa Reynolds went above and beyond all expectations I had of a Realtor. I will always use her for my real estate transactions and will recommend her to everyone. Knowledgeable, focused and on point. Made a potentially difficult time easy.

- Satisfied S

Property Specialties